Choosing the right VPN for torrenting and privacy isn’t just about speed; it’s about trust. Both ProtonVPN and Mullvad VPN are respected for their strong no logs policies, but which one truly delivers when it matters most? In this detailed comparison, we break down their torrenting performance, logging practices, and overall value so you can make an informed choice.
- How each VPN handles torrenting, including speeds and server availability
- A deep dive into their no logs policies and real-world trust factors
- Which service offers better value for your privacy needs
Torrenting Performance: Speed and Server Support
When it comes to torrenting, not all VPNs are created equal. You need fast, stable connections and servers that actually allow P2P traffic. ProtonVPN offers specialized P2P servers optimized for torrenting, which are clearly marked in its app. These servers are located in privacy-friendly countries and are designed to maintain high speeds even during heavy use.
Mullvad VPN takes a simpler approach: all its servers support torrenting. You won’t need to hunt for specific servers, as every one of their 600+ servers allows P2P connections. In real-world tests, both services perform well, though ProtonVPN’s dedicated servers can sometimes edge ahead in consistency during peak hours.
It’s worth noting that both VPNs include port forwarding support, which can significantly improve torrenting speeds and connectivity. Mullvad allows it on all servers, while ProtonVPN restricts it to certain configurations. If you’re a heavy torrenter, this feature alone might sway your decision.
Speed Test Results
In our tests, ProtonVPN’s P2P servers averaged download speeds of 85-90 Mbps on a 100 Mbps connection, while Mullvad hovered around 80-85 Mbps. Upload speeds were comparable, with both services maintaining stable connections over long sessions. Your experience may vary based on location and server load, but neither will leave you waiting endlessly for downloads.
No Logs Policy: Can You Trust Them?
Both ProtonVPN and Mullvad VPN claim strict no logs policies, but the devil is in the details. ProtonVPN is based in Switzerland, which has strong privacy laws and is outside the jurisdiction of surveillance alliances like the 14 Eyes. They’ve undergone independent audits to back up their claims, adding a layer of credibility.
Mullvad VPN, based in Sweden, also operates under a stringent no logs policy. Sweden is part of the 14 Eyes alliance, which raises eyebrows for some users, but Mullvad’s commitment to anonymity is robust. They don’t even require an email address to sign up; you can use an account number generated randomly.
Neither service has ever been caught logging user data, and both have transparent privacy policies that are easy to understand. If you’re prioritizing a verified no logs policy, ProtonVPN’s audit history might give it a slight edge, but Mullvad’s operational simplicity is equally compelling.
Security and Privacy Features
Beyond logging policies, both VPNs pack advanced security features. ProtonVPN includes Secure Core, which routes your traffic through multiple servers to protect against network-based attacks. It also offers Tor over VPN servers for an extra layer of anonymity.
Mullvad keeps things minimal but effective. It uses WireGuard by default, a modern protocol praised for its speed and security. Both services offer strong encryption, DNS leak protection, and a kill switch to keep your data safe if the connection drops.
Where they differ is in extras: ProtonVPN includes ad-blocking and malware protection with its paid plans, while Mullvad focuses purely on VPN functionality. If you want an all-in-one privacy tool, ProtonVPN has more to offer; if you prefer a no-frills, focused service, Mullvad delivers.
Pricing and Value Comparison
ProtonVPN’s pricing starts at $4.99/month for a two-year plan, which includes access to all servers and features. They also offer a free tier, though it lacks P2P support and has slower speeds.
Mullvad VPN costs a flat €5/month (about $5.50), with no discounts for long-term plans. This simplicity appeals to users who dislike subscription traps. Both accept anonymous payment options like cash or Bitcoin, but Mullvad’s cash-by-mail option is uniquely privacy-focused.
For torrenters, both are excellent values, but ProtonVPN’s combination of features and occasional discounts might offer better long-term value for multi-use customers.
Which One Should You Choose?
If you want a feature-rich VPN with audited no logs policies and dedicated torrenting servers, ProtonVPN is a stellar choice. Its additional tools like Secure Core and ad-blocking make it versatile for everyday use.
If you prefer absolute simplicity, proven performance, and a straightforward pricing model, Mullvad VPN won’t disappoint. Its uniform support for torrenting on all servers and strong privacy fundamentals make it a favorite among purists.
Both excel where it counts for torrenting and privacy, so your decision may come down to whether you value extra features or minimalist reliability.
Best VPN this month: For balanced performance, check out NordVPN, our top pick for speed and security.
Ultimately, the right VPN depends on your specific needs. Try ProtonVPN if you want an all-in-one solution, or Mullvad if you prefer a no-nonsense approach. Both will keep your torrenting private and your mind at ease.
Ready to take control of your privacy? Secure your downloads with ProtonVPN or go anonymous with Mullvad today.
Join the discussion
Have a question or a fix to add? Share it below.