Choosing the right VPN for torrenting and privacy can feel overwhelming, but it doesn’t have to be. With so many options claiming to be the best, it’s easy to waste time and money on services that don’t deliver. This comparison breaks down two of the most trusted names in the privacy space—ProtonVPN and Mullvad VPN—so you can make an informed choice that keeps your downloads secure and your identity anonymous.
What you’ll learn:
- Which VPN offers better speeds and reliability for torrenting
- How each service handles privacy, logging, and jurisdiction
- Key differences in pricing, features, and ease of use
Torrenting Performance: Speed and Reliability
When it comes to torrenting, speed and connection stability are non-negotiable. Slow downloads or dropped connections can turn a simple task into a frustrating experience.
ProtonVPN offers specialized P2P-optimized servers in numerous countries, which are designed to handle high-bandwidth activities like torrenting. Their network uses high-speed 10 Gbps servers, and users generally report consistent performance with minimal speed loss. If you’re looking for a balance between privacy and performance, ProtonVPN is a strong contender.
Mullvad VPN takes a more minimalist approach. They don’t label servers specifically for torrenting, but all their servers allow P2P traffic. Mullvad is known for reliability and low latency, though speeds can vary depending on server load. If you prioritize a no-fuss, trustworthy connection over specialized servers, Mullvad delivers.
Privacy and Security: Logging Policies and Jurisdiction
Your VPN should never keep logs of your activity—especially when torrenting. Both ProtonVPN and Mullvad have excellent reputations for privacy, but they operate differently under the hood.
ProtonVPN is based in Switzerland, which has strong privacy laws and is outside the jurisdiction of intelligence alliances like the 14 Eyes. They adhere to a strict no-logs policy, which has been independently audited. All servers run in RAM-disk mode, meaning no data is written to hard drives. Combined with always-on AES-256 encryption and a kill switch, ProtonVPN offers robust security for privacy-conscious users.
Mullvad VPN is headquartered in Sweden, part of the 14 Eyes alliance, which may raise eyebrows. However, Mullvad’s no-logs policy is arguably even more stringent—they don’t even require an email address to sign up. You can use the service completely anonymously by generating an account number. Mullvad also uses RAM-only servers and supports WireGuard® for faster, more secure connections. If absolute anonymity is your goal, Mullvad is hard to beat.
Features and Ease of Use
Not everyone wants to spend time configuring advanced settings. A good VPN should be powerful yet accessible.
ProtonVPN offers user-friendly apps for all major platforms, including Windows, macOS, Android, iOS, and Linux. Features like Secure Core (which routes traffic through privacy-friendly countries) and Tor over VPN provide added layers of security. Their interface is clean and intuitive, making it easy to connect to optimized servers for streaming or torrenting.
Mullvad VPN focuses on simplicity and transparency. Their apps are straightforward, with fewer bells and whistles, but all essential features—like a kill switch and custom DNS—are present. Mullvad also allows port forwarding, which can improve torrenting speeds. While it may not feel as polished as ProtonVPN, it gets the job done with no distractions.
Pricing and Value
Budget matters, but so does value. Here’s how these two stack up in terms of cost.
ProtonVPN offers a free tier, but it does not allow torrenting. Their paid plans start at $4.99/month when committing to a 2-year plan. The Plus plan (required for torrenting) includes access to all servers, high speeds, and up to 10 simultaneous connections. If you want a feature-rich VPN with a free option for light use, ProtonVPN provides flexibility.
Mullvad VPN has one flat rate: €5/month (approximately $5.50 USD), with no discounts for long-term commitments. This simplicity is refreshing—you’re not tricked into a lengthy subscription. Mullvad allows up to 5 simultaneous connections. If you prefer transparent, month-to-month pricing without upsells, Mullvad is an honest choice.
Which One Should You Choose?
So, which VPN is right for you? It depends on what you value most.
Choose ProtonVPN if you want a balance of speed, features, and ease of use. Its dedicated P2P servers, strong privacy protections, and user-friendly apps make it ideal for those new to VPNs or anyone who wants extra functionality like Secure Core or Tor integration.
Choose Mullvad VPN if your top priority is anonymity and simplicity. With no sign-up required, a flat monthly rate, and a proven no-logs policy, Mullvad is perfect for users who want a straightforward, trustworthy VPN without any fluff.
Both services excel in privacy and torrenting support, so you can’t go wrong with either. Your decision ultimately comes down to whether you prefer ProtonVPN’s additional features or Mullvad’s minimalist approach.
Best VPN this month: For those seeking a versatile, high-speed option with excellent torrenting support, ExpressVPN remains a top choice thanks to its reliable performance and strong privacy guarantees.
Ready to take control of your online privacy? Whether you choose ProtonVPN or Mullvad, using a reputable VPN is the first step toward secure, anonymous torrenting. Explore our detailed torrenting guide for more tips, or check out the latest VPN deals to get started today.
Join the discussion
Have a question or a fix to add? Share it below.