Choosing the right VPN for torrenting is a make-or-break decision for your privacy and download speeds. Not all providers support P2P traffic, and those that do vary widely in performance and security. This comparison breaks down two popular options—ProtonVPN and Surfshark—to help you decide which one best fits your torrenting needs. We’ll look at real-world speed tests, privacy features, and overall value so you can torrent safely and efficiently.
- Which VPN offers faster torrenting speeds in real-world tests
- How each service handles privacy, logging, and leak protection
- Which one provides the best value for money with P2P support
Torrenting Performance: Speed and Reliability
When it comes to torrenting, speed isn’t just a luxury—it’s essential. Slow connections can turn a quick download into an all-day affair. Both ProtonVPN and Surfshark support P2P file-sharing, but they take different approaches to managing bandwidth and server load.
In our tests, Surfshark consistently delivered higher average download speeds, especially on nearby servers. Its network is optimized for high-bandwidth activities, and it shows. ProtonVPN, while generally reliable, can be slower during peak hours unless you’re connected to one of its premium Plus servers.
Surfshark uses a technique called NAT firewall to improve torrenting performance while maintaining security. ProtonVPN relies on its secure core architecture, which routes traffic through privacy-friendly countries like Switzerland. This adds a layer of security but can sometimes reduce speed.
Server Availability and P2P Support
Surfshark allows torrenting on all its servers, which means you don’t have to hunt for specific P2P-enabled locations. ProtonVPN restricts torrenting to designated servers, which can sometimes be overcrowded. If you’re looking for flexibility and fewer connection hurdles, Surfshark has the edge.
Privacy and Security Features Compared
Privacy is non-negotiable when torrenting. Your ISP, copyright trolls, and other snoops shouldn’t be able to track what you’re downloading. Both ProtonVPN and Surfshark offer strong security, but there are key differences in their approaches.
ProtonVPN is based in Switzerland, which has some of the world’s strongest privacy laws. It follows a strict no-logs policy and uses RAM-only servers, meaning your data is wiped with every reboot. It also includes a built-in kill switch and DNS leak protection as standard.
Surfshark, headquartered in the Netherlands, also adheres to a no-logs policy and uses RAM-only servers. It goes a step further with its Camouflage Mode, which makes your VPN traffic look like regular HTTPS traffic. This is especially useful in restrictive networks.
Additional Security Tools
Surfshark offers a few extras torrenters will appreciate, like CleanWeb, which blocks ads and malware at the network level. ProtonVPN includes NetShield, an ad and tracker blocker, but it’s only available on paid plans. Both support WireGuard, a modern protocol that balances speed and security beautifully.
Pricing and Value for Torrenting
Budget matters, especially if you’re looking for a long-term VPN solution. Surfshark is generally more affordable, with plans starting as low as $2.29 per month for a two-year subscription. It also allows unlimited simultaneous connections, which is great for sharing with family or friends.
ProtonVPN’s free plan is a standout feature, but it doesn’t allow torrenting. To unlock P2P support, you’ll need at least the Plus plan, which starts at $4.99 per month. While it’s pricier, you’re paying for Proton’s reputation and strong commitment to privacy.
Which One Should You Choose?
If speed and affordability are your top priorities, Surfshark is the better choice. Its unlimited device policy, consistent performance, and lower price make it ideal for most torrenters.
If you prioritize maximum privacy and don’t mind paying a bit more, ProtonVPN is a solid option. Its Swiss jurisdiction and advanced security features provide peace of mind for those who want an extra layer of protection.
Both VPNs are excellent, but your choice depends on what you value most: raw speed and value, or top-tier privacy and trust.
Best VPN this month: Surfshark is offering an exclusive discount for CyberVPNHub readers—get protected now and enjoy blazing-fast torrenting with unlimited devices.
Ready to make your choice? Compare more options in our detailed torrenting VPN guide or check current deals on our VPN deals page. Don’t leave your downloads to chance—secure your connection today.
Join the discussion
Have a question or a fix to add? Share it below.